X-farmerdan
Well-Known Member
I’ve ready a lot and studied both crop oil and surfactants. And, when I ran the coop many moons ago I sold more crop oil than surfactant. The herbicide label should be your guide. Research would tell the effectiveness of each used with the herbicide in question and the weeds it is labeled to control.
Having said that, the line between the two adjuvants is murky. I’m going simple here and will be technically wrong in a general way. Each weed species has its own leaf surface characteristics designed to minimize loss of internal “good stuff” while maximizing protection against intrusion of “bad stuff.” As growers, our need is to defeat both systems. Surfactants and crop oils are good for the job. Which is better depends on the weed and herbicide mode of action.
Personal experience? Always crop oil for me. Can it burn? Yes, but rarely at recommended rates, usually 1% of the mixed spray solution. While there’s no scientific evidence for what I do, I will sometimes up the percentages of crop oil where there is an immediate threat of rain and/ or where weeds are beyond their optimum kill size.
Bottom line? I dunno....
Having said that, the line between the two adjuvants is murky. I’m going simple here and will be technically wrong in a general way. Each weed species has its own leaf surface characteristics designed to minimize loss of internal “good stuff” while maximizing protection against intrusion of “bad stuff.” As growers, our need is to defeat both systems. Surfactants and crop oils are good for the job. Which is better depends on the weed and herbicide mode of action.
Personal experience? Always crop oil for me. Can it burn? Yes, but rarely at recommended rates, usually 1% of the mixed spray solution. While there’s no scientific evidence for what I do, I will sometimes up the percentages of crop oil where there is an immediate threat of rain and/ or where weeds are beyond their optimum kill size.
Bottom line? I dunno....