I haven't had any luck on shrubs that don't need some protection beside Speckled Alder. I have plum, chokecherry, highbrush cranberry, dogwood (grey and red), and ninebark. All those mentioned have been browsed to the ground in my area. I started tubing chokecherry and plum for the first season to get them started. Experimenting on a few this year and pulled the tube after they hit 4' to see if they can handle the browse without protection.
But the Speckled Alders are bullet proof. They are my go-to for establishing my screening projects.