Yep, I normally use 5 foot on fruit trees and then when they get bigger, I will cut some of the top off and bring them back to about 4 - once the tops can't be browsed anymore.
This was a place in the back near a property line where I had never been able to get pines established, but needed them for screening there. I thought I would save a little money and use 4 foot here, because I was only worried about rubbing and not so much about the tops being browsed. They will browse pine tops some but it doesn't hurt them like it does fruit trees.
I don't think any extra height would have made a difference here. That deer was determined to rub the tree.
I did some walking yesterday and saw more rubbing than I have ever seen before. I had a few other pines that weren't caged, and a high percentage of them got whacked. Also found some big oak damage from the bad storm this summer. I hadn't been back there since the storm. Three big oaks close to each other that were either uprooted or twisted off. You may remember me doing cleanup back then at the places I did go to after the storm.
Glad I wasn't in this ladder stand. Look at the center of the pic in the background.
.