So out of curiosity, I went to the TETHRD site and then watched a bunch of his videos on youtube I just don't see the appeal. Facing the tree, knees against the tree to keep from swinging inward. Dude carries knee pads in his pack! WTF? Very complicated, needing lots of extra ropes, etc. The videos I watched, the guy even had some rigged backrest that was made from an old bino strap and two more prusics. Really???? Outside of light weight, where's the appeal? I'm sure I'm missing it so help me out.
1st, I would ask you what your preferred method of stand hunting is?
The reality is that there is no perfect system of being elevated for deer hunting. Whether its a shooting box, ladder stand, climber, conventional hang-ons, or saddles, they all have their attributes and challenges. For this discussion, I'm tossing boxes and ladders out of the conversation. They are an entirely different animal.
Every hunter has their own set of requirements or comfort zones. For
my needs, Ive never liked a climber. They are too cumbersome to pack in and out; They need to be rigged and unrigged before and after each and every hunt; They are noisy to climb on many types of trees; And my biggest issue with climbers is they limit which trees I can hunt from. I stopped using climbers back in the 1980s and haven't regretted it for a minute.
Until the last few years, pre-set hang on stands have been my only method. I own a bunch of them and for the most part, they work out okay, but they do have limitations on tree size, tree lean, or even the side of the tree I can hang the stand.
Saddles are not plug 'n play. If a guy doesn't want to take the initial efforts to get it dialed-in then he probably doesn't have the right mindset to begin with, but if he goes into it with an open mind and eager to learn, there is a good chance he will become a convert. That's exactly what happened with me.
Climbing methods for saddles is no different than for a hang-on, so throw that out of the equation. Ropes? I have 2 ropes with a saddle...My lineman's rope and my tether. With a simple and organized rope management system, ropes are not complicated in the least.
Knee pads...They are not an absolute necessity if you are primarily a leaner, but they are helpful and they are necessary if you are a sitter.
I use Arc Teryx knee pads and they have become one of my favorite pieces of gear. They are very compatible for wearing while walking. No sag, lightweight, and I forget I'm even wearing them...until I have a need to kneel down while walking. There are times when we should kneel...If deer approach me while I'm walking I want to get as low to the ground as possible. They are much less likely to see me if I kneel as opposed to just stand there and hope they pass me by. Another reason to get on a knee is to squirm thru tight spots along the trail. My woods have become a maze of roadblocks since the ash border has invaded. What was an open access trail yesterday, is often blocked by newly fallen ash trees and stooping, bending and kneeling is sometimes required to get thru. I used to think knee pads would be a hassle but I've come to really appreciate them.
As far as actually being in the tree with a saddle,
for me there is no better method. I can hunt many more types of trees, size, lean, and branches are a lot less of an issue with saddles when compared to ANY other elevated stand. 360 shooting. Concealment. Zero chance of stand theft. Mobility. Safety. Comfort (I can even nap in my saddle if I wish).
The latest generation of saddles have come a long way since the days of the old Trophy Line. And the creativity that guys are using to fine tune their gear to their needs seems to have no bounds. Just when I think it's great, someone comes up with a little (or not so little) tweak that makes it even better. I'm 61 and I've just completed my 49th deer season. I've spent literally many thousand hours in trees. I wish it didn't take this many years to discover saddles. You young guys have fantastic gear that has only become commercially available in the last few years and it's getting better and better. Don't knock saddles until you've given them an honest try.
Last point...
They are the most effective way to be in a tree. No doubt in the mind of this old-timer.